What did you think? Did you swoon when all the judges swooned? Barfed when they barfed? (Do you notice that they all swoon and barf together?) Anyhoo, here is my "Idle" opinion of last night:
Jackie Tohn !: (aka New York Girl Clamoring for Attention by Being the Crazy Rocker Girl) Covered Elvis's "Conversation" song--a little too much conversation for me, honey, not enough strong singing.
Ricky Braddy: To me, he is Clay Aiken. Think about it. The North Carolina accent, the vocals, the likely fan base. If you liked him, you like Clay Aiken. That's my equation, and I'm sticking to it.
Alexis Grace: Lotsa praise for this little lady, and she is good, but I think she seems a little artificial. Or maybe amateuer. But amateur ain't bad on a show like this.
Brent Keith: Horrible, and I hate horrible excuses like, "But America will like me!" ALSO, I love how everyone is playing the "I'm-a-blue-collar worker-card when they're, like, former stars of Nashville Star or a Calendar Model, which leads me to...
Casey Carlson: Yep, she sucked, but she was sexy when she whimpered "everything he does just turns me
on," yeah?
Stevie Wright: Now I didn't think she was that bad! Vocals were not great, but I liked that song, and her little excited jumping on stage. But she's out.
Michael Sarver: Not great, not horrible, kinda karaoke actually, but a true blue collar worker.
Anoop Desai: ANOOP! I LOVE YOU! I'm on the bandwagon, fo sho! He has such a nice tone to his voice, and I love me some geeks. Wonder if they will make him pluck his eyebrows?
Stephen Fowler: Ugh, he was so my fave, but he did a corny performanse, I agree. Sigh. Hopefully America or the judges can see his Cool Dude potential though.
Anne Marie Boskovich: I like her. She has potential and her tone is pretty. She will get through on wild card.
Tatiana del Toro: OH MY! She played the subdued card last night! That clever bitch! Look, we all know she isn't terrible, but she is totally playing mind games with us. Is she crazy or just confused? I think she's smarter than she seems by confusing us with her "I'm not crazy...tonight...game." It's like when Sanjaya wouls tease us with a crazy hairdo and horrible performance one night, and then be normal-ish the next night. And that took him far. CRACKED UP when The Toro put in her little plea to the audience "to vote because this is my dream." Only this bull would say that bullshit, cloying line!
Danny Gokey: He was great, wasn't he? Definite early favorite. But too much hype?
Safe Predictions: Anoop, Danny, Alexis